Iran: The Fix is In and It's Worse Than You Think

by: Shaun Appleby

Sat Jun 13, 2009 at 01:14:17 AM EDT



It's now 9:30AM in the morning in Iran and the Iranian people are awakening to a nation in which the political landscape, though superficially unchanged, is indeliably altered.  Overnight a sensational result has emerged in the Iranian elections for the presidency.  Sensational in the magnitude of the result, close to 65% of the vote for the incumbent, firebrand Mahmud Ahmadinejad and a crushing defeat for his opponent Mousavi.

And it's unlikely to be merely that a populist 'green revolution' has been nipped in the bud by the forces of reaction in Iran's heirarchy, though that in itself is clearly true:


[MARGARET WARNER:] So, you think that the possibility is that you have -- you have seen some government interference here?

CLIFF KUPCHAN: I think, so far, not so good. Now, it's really early, and we don't know.

But the fear is that the establishment didn't like what they were seeing.

Margaret Warner - Iran's Future Unclear Following Presidential Election PBS 12 Jun 09

Yes, interference, with an unprecedented call of the election early for Ahmadinejad, but it isn't what you think:


MARGARET WARNER: But didn't this also expose some fissures in the conservative class...

AFSHIN MOLAVI: Absolutely.

MARGARET WARNER: ... and among the clerics?

AFSHIN MOLAVI: Absolutely.

You know, Ahmadinejad's challenge to the old-guard revolutionary elite was absolutely very important, because it exposed this rift. Ahmadinejad comes from a second-generation revolutionary elite. They cut their political teeth in the fight against Iraq, whereas the old-guard elite cut their teeth in the fight against the shah.

These two are at each other right now. That is going to have ramifications beyond the election.

Margaret Warner - Iran's Future Unclear Following Presidential Election PBS 12 Jun 09

As was suggested in a recent diary this election has become a contest for internal power within the oligarchy, which revealed it's topography in unprecedented ways in the course of the presidential debates.  What we appear to be seeing is the passing of power from the old generation to the new generation of conservative revolutionary elites.

Shaun Appleby :: Iran: The Fix is In and It's Worse Than You Think

Ahmadinejad's sensational accusations of corruption during the televised debates were a challenge to the established oligarchy and it is likely his electoral success, fraud or not, represents an upheaval in the internal balance of power in his favour.  From a policy point of view the election of Mousavi would not have substantially altered Iranian politics except to shift the rhetoric slightly on engagement and redirect investment of revenue to infrastructure rather that wages and gratuitous, inflationary payments to the rural and urban poor.  And the oligarchy doesn't give a fig about the aspirations of urban, middle-class voters who supported Mousavi and alarmed them with public demonstrations.

No, this was a competition to see who could demonstrate the most influence to determine the outcome, a metric of how many provincial Interior Ministry officials could be enlisted to cook the books for one candidate or the other.  It is close to being a coup d'├ętat within the context of the power to manipulate the system reserved for the oligarchic heirarchy.  And Ahmadinejad has clearly emerged the victor.

Mousavi's defeat is not the compelling story, it's the nature of his defeat, involving accusations of corruption against Rafsanjani, an open letter of protest to Khamenei and clear divisions among the ruling elite:


MARGARET WARNER: And -- and I know you are making a point that are you're not speculating here, just that's the fear among Moussavi's supporters.

Either way, whoever wins this -- and we, of course, may have a runoff next Friday -- fair to say this has been an incredible campaign, an unexpectedly intense one.

AFSHIN MOLAVI: Absolutely, probably the most polarizing presidential election in Iran's 30 year post-revolution history.

The televised debates, Margaret, were -- were absolutely spectacular to watch. They were more like a smack-down than debates, with candidates hurling insults at each other. Essentially, Ahmadinejad also opened a whole file in which he called his opponent members of a corrupt business elite.

And when these elections are over, those accusations are going to hang in the air as an albatross over the entire system of the Islamic republic.

Margaret Warner - Iran's Future Unclear Following Presidential Election PBS 12 Jun 09

Surely the organs of state power have been used to manage the situation, from the blackout of SMS services on election day:


Radio Farda, RFE/RL's Persian Service, confirmed that, at first, text messages from the two reformist presidential candidates were blocked from reaching supporters on Thursday evening. Eventually, Iran's entire SMS infrastructure went down. As of Friday night, service has not been restored.

An official from Iran's state telecommunications company confirmed the SMS disruption and said, vaguely, that it may have been caused by "other entities" in the government.

Textless in Tehran: Huge Turnout Despite SMS Disruptions Radio Free Europe 12 Jun 09

To the raid on Mousavi's election headquarters late in the evening:


Police raided and emptied presidential candidate Mir Hossein Mousavi's central campaign headquarters, a STRATFOR source close to the Iranian political establishment said June 12. The source also said two key reformist leaders close to Mousavi have been arrested. A STRATFOR source in Iranian media said police took over Mousavi's headquarters to keep his campaign organizers from launching a potential coordinated demonstration.

Iran: Police Clear Out Mousavi's Headquarters Stratfor 12 Jun 09 2346 GMT

For those who missed the day's news, Mousavi claimed victory early and Iran's state run media immediately declared a huge margin for his opponent in an unprecedented early result:


Official preliminary results show that Iran's incumbent President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad is leading the polls with 69.04 percent of the ballots that have so far been counted.

In a surprise press briefing, Iran's Election Commission Chief, Kamran Daneshjoo, announced that 19.42 percent of the votes were counted until 23:54 local time (20:24 GMT).

According to Daneshjoo, Ahmadinejad is leading in the polls, followed by Mir-Hossein Mousavi who has 28.42 percent of the votes.

Ahmadinejad leads Mousavi in preliminary results PressTV (Iran) 12 Jun 09 20:07:15 GMT

Never mind they were still printing ballots:


Election Day draws to a close in Iran with the Guardian Council printing more ballot papers in the heat of a seemingly unprecedented voter turnout.

The Guardian Council, an influential body tasked with overseeing the election process, announced that a new amount of ballot papers have been printed in the final hours of the presidential polls.

More ballot papers printed over high turnout PressTV (Iran) 12 Jun 09 18:26:30 GMT

Not that these ballots were found anywhere they were needed:


Voting stations in Shiraz and Tabriz, Iran, ran out of ballots very quickly during the country's presidential election June 12, Aftab News reported June 13. These areas are known to be home to many supporters of presidential candidate Mir Hossein Mousavi, Aftab said. Furthermore, a STRATFOR source in Iranian media said voters in Shiraz were turned away because of a ballot shortage. The source said electoral authorities told voters to go home and return for a "second round" of voting. Aftab reported that voting stations in southern Tehran, where Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad has many supporters, had excess ballots.

Iran: Ballot Supply Irregularities Reported Stratfor 13 Jun 09 0133 GMT

And the outcome?  A landslide:


Partial results show that Iran's incumbent President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad is close to winning the elections in a landslide victory, gaining 64.31 percent of the votes.

His campaign manager Mojtaba Samareh Hashemi has already claimed victory.

According to Press TV's correspondent at the Election Commission Headquarters, Saman Kojouri, the latest statistics announced by the Iranian electoral officials show 94 percent of the ballots have been counted so far.

Ahmadinejad close to a landslide victory PressTV (Iran) 13 Jun 09 00:44:19 GMT

Not without an alarming report mid-evening from Stratfor on the whole ordeal:


The Iranian election is currently in turmoil. Both Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad and challenger Mir Hossein Mousavi are claiming to be ahead in the vote. Preliminary results from the presidential vote show Ahmadinejad leading; Iranian Election Commission chief Kamran Daneshjoo held a press conference at 11:45 p.m. local time and announced that with some 20 percent of the votes counted, the president was leading with 3,462,548 votes (69.04 percent), while his main challenger, Mousavi, had 1, 425,678 (28.42 percent). Sources tell STRATFOR that these preliminary numbers pertain to the votes from the smaller towns and villages, where the president has considerable influence, as he has distributed a lot of cash to the poor.

However, Iran's state-run Press TV is saying that only 10 million of 24 million votes, or around 42 percent of the vote, have been counted. At the same time, they are also claiming that 69 percent of the vote has been counted. Obviously the numbers are not adding up, and the agencies themselves appear to be in chaos.

Prior to the announcement of the results, Mousavi held a press conference in which he said he was the winner of the election. The opposition camp is greatly concerned about fraud, and STRATFOR has been told that Mousavi has vowed to resist any fraud, even if it entails taking to the streets. This means there is considerable risk of unrest should Ahmadinejad emerge as the winner. But so far there is no evidence that the government is mobilizing security forces to deal with any such eventuality.

The situation is being monitored carefully, as it is potentially explosive.

Red Alert: Iran's Election Results 12 Jun 09 2116 GM

The upshot?  Mousavi lost, big time.  So big time as to challenge the probity of the election and the credulity of the electorate as a high turnout, and it was awesome, was supposed to favour Mousavi and Ahmadinejad's base has been variously estimated as between 12 and 14 million, tops.  But that's not the point.

Ahmadinejad won by a margin calculated to shake the confidence of members of the oligarchy who arguably pulled out all the stops to oppose him.  He has demonstrated a level of control of the state apparatus which exceeds our previous estimates, and clearly the narrow-eyed world-view of Ahmadinejad has just received a vote of confidence and may reach further into the oligarchy's labyrinthine corridors of power than we previously had thought or anticipated.

It is also clear that Mousavi's constiuencies have been marginalised and ignored, that the advocates of the 'green revolution,' now likely to be resentful and skeptical of Iran's legal mechanisms for democracy, have been sidelined in the competition for power among the elites.  They may live to regret this when these chickens come home to roost.

But even more clearly the prospects of an emerging willingness for engagement, a softening of the bombastic rhetoric of Holocaust denial and aggression and an opportunity for moderation of Iran's isolation and ambition for raw power has been, for the moment, irretrievably lost.

The next few days and weeks will be very interesting, as Iranians of all classes and persuasions awaken to this new reality.  Ahmadinejad, the outspoken demagogue who has been rightly dismissed in the past as a mere puppet of his oligarchic masters is tugging on the strings himself and seems to have a pretty firm grip so far.

Tags: (All Tags)
Print Friendly View Send As Email

No I'm worried. (2.00 / 4)
Iran has worried me less and less for the past while.  Now it worries me way more.

John Askren - "Never get into a pissing match with a skunk."

Re: Now I'm worried (2.00 / 3)
Me too.  I really see this as a coup which took some of the leadership by surprise.  Not to mention this:


Security officials and riot police engaged in violent clashes with demonstrators in Tehran today in what one reporter called an "unprecedented scene" in Iran in recent years.

Iran Demonstrations: Violent Clashes Between Protestors And Riot Police Huffington Post (MSNBC) 13 Jun 09

I certainly sympathise with them.


[ Parent ]
Ahmadi had turned Iran into a fascist regime. Every single (2.00 / 4)
thing the ruling elite had done to steal the election, and now suppressing the voices of opposition are hallmarks of a oppressive regime.  

Re: Fascism (2.00 / 3)
You might have even said national-socialist.  The ramifications of this event have raised in my own mind the parallels between Ahmadinejad and a certain German corporal:

* world-view framed in a bitter, bloody war

* virulent anti-Semitism with rumours of Jewish ancestry

* ascetic and incorruptable

* originally considered a tool of religious and industrial political factions

* ingratiated with and supported by military and security organs of state power

* intensely nationalist

* espoused 'socialist' working class values

* aggressively challenged international authority

* rhetoric laced with bombastic demagoguery

And so forth.  This chap worries me, frankly, and makes me glad I spent so many years reading the history of the early Third Reich.  We often forget that Hitler's rise to power was by plurality election and political coalition, through a complex society with real power diffused through many different centres, not unlike Iran's oligarchic theocracy.  He was underestimated, gained a populist following, stole an election or two, placed allies in control of the security apparatus then... whammo, the Enabling Act of 1933 was the last thing the Reichstag ever did beside applaud.

This little tyrant scares me, we will be watching his career with great interest.


[ Parent ]
yes..that's true. The question is what it would take for him (2.00 / 3)
to overthrow the overlord Khamenei and rest of the Supreme Council Guardians? Not much...

You have made the right comparison...throw in religious fundamentalism, the cocktail is pretty bad. This dude is scary...


[ Parent ]
I'm worried too (2.00 / 5)
I had hoped Iran could pull off what we did last November, but apparently not. Imagine how we would have felt if McCain had won.

I love my country, but I think we should start seeing other people.

Re: I'm worried too (2.00 / 4)
Imagine how we would have felt if McCain controlled the Justice Department and every election board, won by a 30% margin and had Blackwater clear out the Democratic campaign headquarters and arrest Axelrod and Gibbs a few hours after the polls closed with rumours flying that Obama had been detained by military intelligence.  That's basically what just happened to Iran.

[ Parent ]
wuh-oh. (2.00 / 4)
"The election results are incredible. It's just nonsense ... If it was a genuine election landslide, surely people should be out on the streets in euphoria.  The potential for unrest is high. People will wake up today in Iran in a state of shock, not that Ahmadinejad has won, but that he has won on such a dramatic scale ... The scale of the election victory that they have given Ahmadinejad means he must have won big in the cities. That is simply not borne out by what people were saying in the major cities (before the vote)."

LI ANSARI, DIRECTOR OF INSTITUTE FOR IRANIAN STUDIES AT UNIVERSITY OF ST ANDREWS IN SCOTLAND

"I spend my days and nights pondering the meaning of life, the state of the universe, and the Home Shopping Network." -- Donald Roller Wilson


Re: wuh-oh (2.00 / 3)
I'm wondering what 'legitimacy' issues may arise as a consequence of this staggeringly incredible result.

[ Parent ]
Someone who is supposed to be an expert on Iran (2.00 / 4)
(and might be for all I know) said on CNN last night that Ahmadinejad's folks might have done too good a job rigging the election.  It will be hard for anyone to reconcile the results with was coming out of the country in the run-up to the election (and what we're seeing now).

"When Fascism comes to America, it will come wrapped in teh stupid and waving a gun" ~ Esteev on Wonkette

[ Parent ]
neat observation (2.00 / 3)
when the pugs stole 2004 they had sophisticated programs that changed the votes by only a tad.  They didn't get the numbers right in 2006, and Barack was so far ahead in all the polls this time that it was impossible to rig without being caught, a la Iran.  This will not sit with with Iranian kids.  

What, me worry?

[ Parent ]
There are all sorts of irregularities showing up (2.00 / 3)
The vote percentage for each candidate held remarkably steady as each new vote total was reported, regardless of what region the votes came from. Mousavi even lost his home district by about the same margin as any other region of the country.

The vote was on hand-marked ballots and was counted in a very short time. By law, the count was also supposed to be held for 3 days to allow challenges and then approved by the Supreme Leader. This was done in one day.

One of Mousavi's campaign officials said the election ministry contacted them to report Mousavi's victory and to start planning for a smooth transition.

This is beginning to look more and more like a clumsy vote rigging attempt on the part of the current power structure.

Andrew Sullivan has been all over this today. It's the only thing he's covering on his blog, which is very unusual. He's got lots of good info, videos, and links.


This is not a recession. It's a robbery.


It does seem beyond odd that the vote percentage stayed (2.00 / 2)
so remarkably stable.  From what I heard they expected Ahmadinejad to start strong because he is popular in the rural areas.  That Mousavi never closed that gap really makes it look like the fix was in.

It also seems like they counted those votes really quickly.

The next few days might be very interesting.

"When Fascism comes to America, it will come wrapped in teh stupid and waving a gun" ~ Esteev on Wonkette


[ Parent ]
That, is awesome (2.00 / 2)
as long as they members of the board survive the next 24 hours.  I hear there is a real bad flu going around Tehran...

John Askren - "Never get into a pissing match with a skunk."

[ Parent ]
Re: That, is awesome (2.00 / 2)
'Fascist swine flu?'

[ Parent ]
way beyond odd (2.00 / 1)
when the exit polls called it for Kerry, it was assumed by our in-bed press that the exit polls were wrong. That did a world-wide disservice for elections.  

What, me worry?

[ Parent ]
[Breaking]: Protest contines in Iran (2.00 / 4)
The mainstream media has completely dropped the ball on this one, check out #IranElection on Twitter and www.tehranbureau.com, things are still going crazy at 4AM in Tehran and it seems like the protest is sustaining some momentum.

Yeah... (2.00 / 3)
But that's hours old.  Latest tweet on #iranelection 'Mousavi just said his prayers @ the HQ and is moving toward ministry with 30000 supporters.'  Been quiet this morning except for some tear gas at universities in Tehran and Isfahan, apparently.

[ Parent ]
The TehranBureau.com had been blocked last couple of hours. (2.00 / 1)


[ Parent ]
Back Up Now (2.00 / 1)
Mainstream media has been missing this story in a big way.  What's the point of having a 24-hour news cycle if you just do popular culture pap when a story like this is breaking?

[ Parent ]
I know..methinks Dailykos is doing an awesome job (2.00 / 1)
covering it. NYT has some news, WaPo practically nothing.
All the TV news cable are practically out of sync now...

results of hardly any or few foreign correspondents?


[ Parent ]
Yeah... (2.00 / 1)
DailyKos really proves it's value at times like this.  Check this out.

[ Parent ]
yep CNN just finished a coverage of Iran...they called (2.00 / 1)
it an "unrest"....CNNFail!!!

[ Parent ]
Ahmadi tries to fuck Iran! Sorry for the language (2.00 / 3)
Ouch...I knew my outrage at Ahmadi's fascist (2.00 / 2)
behavior was treading a thin line and it fell on Blask Lord strict pen..:) Sorry..

[ Parent ]
The unrest seems to be limited to scattered riots (2.00 / 1)
and protests today. If it dies out over the next couple of days then the results will stand. The one way I see that the people could force a revote is if the opposition can organize a national strike. Text messaging is still down, but cell phone service has apparently been restored. It would be difficult, but not impossible to organize a strike.

This is not a recession. It's a robbery.

Mousavi has called for a general strike for Tuesday. (2.00 / 1)
It will be interesting to see how much traction he gets given the lack of communications

"When Fascism comes to America, it will come wrapped in teh stupid and waving a gun" ~ Esteev on Wonkette

[ Parent ]
The safety of Moussavi: (2.00 / 2)
Christiane Amanpour asked Ahmadinnerjacket if he would guarantee Mr. Moussavi's safety, and he answered:

"When a person runs a red light they have to pay a penalty."

Military dictators aren't usually good at managing the safety of their opposition...

John Askren - "Never get into a pissing match with a skunk."


I'm feeling a little weepy today. (2.00 / 1)
I think the pain from the Iranians is palpable, it's in the air.  I've been where they are so I sympathize on that level too.

I was watching the youTube video posted on Crooks & Liars called 50 people, 1 question.  The question was "What would you wish to happen by the end of the day?"  I kept thinking "I wish for either a fair recount or a new election in Iran."  Weird, huh?


I wish it was that simple. (2.00 / 1)
I don't see any way the powers that be in Iran can do a recount without looking really bad. A new election would be rigged just like this one was, so that's not much of an option. Maybe they can set up a scapegoat in the Interior Ministry and blame them for releasing false numbers. This would get Khamenei off the hook.

This is not a recession. It's a robbery.

[ Parent ]
It's getting worse. (2.00 / 3)
Blood is flowing on the streets of Tehran. The authorities are starting to raid college dorms and students are getting beaten. It's going to get a lot uglier before it is over.

crime in university of Shiraz/Iran #iranelection on Twitpic



This is not a recession. It's a robbery.


For perspective's sake (2.00 / 1)
Boston.com's photostream from the election only a few days ago...

Note the difference in the view of the Azadi Monument then and now...


[ Parent ]
Search




Advanced Search
Menu

Make a New Account

Username:

Password:



Forget your username or password?


Blog Roll
Angry Bear
Angry Black Lady
Balloon Juice
Black Kos
Booman Tribune
Charles P. Pierce
Crooks and Liars
Daily Kos
Five Thirty Eight
Huffington Post
Juan Cole
Maddow Blog
P.M. Carpenter
Political Wire
RumpRoast
Scholars & Rogues
Smartypants
Stonekettle Station
Talking Points Memo
The Field
Washington Monthly
Wonkette
Moose With Blogs
Atdleft
Barr
BorderJumpers
BTchakir
Canadian Gal
Charles Lemos
Cheryl Kopec
Curtis Walker
Douglas Watts
Hubie Stubert
Intrepid Liberal
ItStands
Janicket
JoeTrippi
John Allen
LibraryGrape
MichaelEvan
National Gadfly
Peter Jukes
Senate Guru
Zachary Karabell




Back to Top

Posting Guidelines  |  FAQ  |  Privacy Policy  |  Contact the Moose  |  Contact Congress
Powered by: SoapBlox