BP Failed Long Before the BOP* Failed

by: jsfox

Fri Jun 11, 2010 at 14:05:07 PM EDT


Bookmark and Share

*BOP = Blow out Preventor

I do not often recommend that folks head over to the WSJ for anything, but today I make an exception. As BP continues to spin this disaster as a failure of technology - the BOP's failure. Someone from the oil and gas industry has finally come along and declared Bull Shit!

Terry Barr, the writer of this letter to the editor in response to Hayward's WSJ Op Ed on June 4th, is President of Samson Oil and Gas Limited  which is a Australian based oil & gas company holding extensive development and exploration acreage in the USA. So I think the man knows of which he speaks.  He clearly lays the blame on BP and the failure of it's people to follow standard industry practices that could have prevented this disaster BOP failure or not.


image courtesy the Young Turks

jsfox :: BP Failed Long Before the BOP* Failed
Just one of the money quotes:

WSJ.com

   

Mr. Hayward and BP have taken the position that this tragedy is all about a fail-safe blow-out preventer (BOP) failing, but in reality the BOP is really the backup system, and yes we expect that it will work. However, all of the industry practice and construction systems are aimed at ensuring that one never has to use that device. Thus the industry has for decades relied on a dense mud system to keep the hydrocarbons in the reservoir and everything that is done to maintain wellbore integrity is tested, and where a wellbore integrity test fails, remedial action is taken.

   This well failed its casing integrity test and nothing was done. The data collected during a critical operation to monitor hydrocarbon inflow was ignored and nothing was done. This spill is about human failure and it is time BP put its hand up and admitted that.

I strongly suggest every one head over to WSJ and read the whole play by play as laid out by Mr. Barr. It's clear, concise and lays the blame squarely where it must be put. BP!

Tags: (All Tags)
Print Friendly View Send As Email

Bookmark and Share
Thanks for the heads-up. (2.00 / 6)
Making tracks to WSJ now.

I am but here (2.00 / 6)
to serve ;)

[ Parent ]
Okey dokey. (2.00 / 5)
First let me say that I have only half a clue what Terry Barr is talking about ~ my fault much more than his.

What he does say, though, tracks with what I've read and heard elsewhere, namely that there were, or should have been, warning signs early on that there were problems.  The explosion occurred during a transition time (frankly, I don't remember what they were transitioning to or from) is highly unusual because this is supposed to be a fairly stable time.  I also find it hard to beleive that any responsible well owner would rely on one piece of equipment to control what anyone would guess could be a major catastrophe should something go wrong.

It would seem that BP is trying to shift the blame from either shoddy workmanship and/or materials and/or a serious lack of supervision to a piece of equipment largely to avoid even more expensive wrongful death suits.


As an aside that I hope doesn't take us too far from the original (2.00 / 4)
intent of this fine diary, I was almost side-tracked by the article listed on the right-hand side of the WSJ informing the reader that there is an alien in the White House.  Apparently, returning the bust of Winston Churchill touched a nerve.

[ Parent ]
Ah yes (2.00 / 4)
the Dorothy Rabinowitz piece, truly loathsome.

[ Parent ]
If you are interested (2.00 / 4)
and haven't seen it you should see the interview with the Deepwater Horizon rig worker. Barr's account  supports, in greater detail, what the rig worker describes.

60 Minutes


[ Parent ]
Thanks to who ever added (2.00 / 5)
the image and for Young Turks for supplying it.

Adding images is the one thing I have yet to figure out. Then again I haven't really tried all that hard to figure it out either :)


It was the Magic Moose Pixies (2.00 / 3)
They're tricky, that way...



"Conway, whom experience had taught that rudeness was by no means a guarantee of good faith, was even less inclined to regard a well-turned phrase as a proof of insincerity."  James Hilton, Lost Horizon


[ Parent ]
btw, adding images is simple (2.00 / 4)
just put this into your comment/diary:

<img src="http://photochicken.com/unicornporn.jpg">

"Conway, whom experience had taught that rudeness was by no means a guarantee of good faith, was even less inclined to regard a well-turned phrase as a proof of insincerity."  James Hilton, Lost Horizon


[ Parent ]
i totally shoulda... (2.00 / 5)
...copyrighted the 'unicorn porn' thing. It coulda been my legacy.  sigh.

It's a terrible thing to look over your shoulder when you are trying to lead, and find no one there. -Franklin Roosevelt

[ Parent ]
Ah, but you can't copyright (2.00 / 4)
something like that because...

Unicorn porn belongs to all the world!

Truly a universal delight.

"I now am bold to say to the swift changing hours,
Pass, pass upon your way, for I grow never old,
Fleet to the dark abysm with all your fading flowers,
One rose that none may pluck, within my heart I hold."


[ Parent ]
God damn it! (2.00 / 4)
One of these days I am going to remember fail comes before fierce. Sorry Fogiv for letting that fail linger. Just not paying close attention. Like that is something new ;(

[ Parent ]
heh. no problemo! (2.00 / 2)


It's a terrible thing to look over your shoulder when you are trying to lead, and find no one there. -Franklin Roosevelt

[ Parent ]
Don't feel bad. (2.00 / 3)
Last summer I went through the comments of a diary and failed quite a few.  I even wondered who was so unhappy about the comments until navybluewife commented that "happy wasn't very happy" and I realized the mass failer was me.  Since I'm no longer a TU at DailyKos I don't get so confused.

[ Parent ]
Not to be snippy, but . . . (2.00 / 2)
I was always taught to praise first, criticize second. That's the reason I get confused. That's my story and I am sticking to it :)

[ Parent ]
just be sure to save image to (2.00 / 6)
something like photobucket, imageshack, or flicker first...and don't steal bandwidth (Ya might end up with a gnasty image posted under your name).

Personally, I like Photobucket...though, I'll have to check out Blask's suggestion of photochicken.
Photobucket

"And now here is my secret, a very simple secret;
it is only with the heart that one can see rightly,
what is essential is invisible to the eye."
~Antoine de Saint-Exupéry


[ Parent ]
That bird is strangely mesmerizing. (2.00 / 2)
In a sad way.

[ Parent ]
Search




Advanced Search
Menu

Make a New Account

Username:

Password:



Forget your username or password?


Blog Roll
Andrew Bacevich
Angry Bear
Balloon Juice
Booman Tribune
C4O Democrats
Crooks and Liars
Daily Kos
Five Thirty Eight
Glenn Greenwald
Huffington Post
Juan Cole
MYDD
Open Left
RumpRoast
Scholars & Rogues
The Field
Wonkette
VetVoice
Moose With Blogs
Atdleft
Barr
BorderJumpers
Brit
BTchakir
Canadian Gal
Charles Lemos
Cheryl Kopec
Curtis Walker
Douglas Watts
Hubie Stubert
John Allen
Intrepid Liberal
ItStands
JoeTrippi
LibraryGrape
MichaelEvan
National Gadfly
Senate Guru
Zachary Karabell




Advertisement


Back to Top

Posting Guidelines  |  FAQ  |  Privacy Policy  |  Contact the Moose  |  Contact Congress
Powered by: SoapBlox